All I Want for Christmas is for You to Stop Wearing That

This year, I am selflessly giving up my quota of Santa requests to ask for gifts that will benefit all of mankind. Namely, the abolishment of certain trends/items of clothing that have brought us nothing but horror and despair.

How Santa wants to accomplish the extinction of these fashions—by killing off those perpetuating them, rendering said perpetrators invisible, focusing instead on the producers or the garments themselves—is at his discretion. I won’t tell Santa how to do his job.

(Though I WILL say that sending a small plane carrying Dov Charney, whomever is responsible for Chico’s, and everyone involved in the costuming for the second Sex and the City movie plummeting into frigid Atlantic waters would be an excellent start.)

I will be content to see the end of the following:

1. LEATHER PANTS (or any pant made of vinyl, pvc, or leather-facsimile)

I know. You’re offended. You had a pair of leather pants, and they were damn hot! What am I trying to say? Who do I think I am?

Look. I’m sure there are plenty of people who are visions of loveliness with their legs swaddled in cowhide or a synthetic echo of such. I’ve never seen these people in person, but I believe that they exist, because look:

kate moss leather pants 369x800 All I Want for Christmas is for You to Stop Wearing That

Alas, you remember kindergarten? How if one student abused a privilege, the privilege was then rescinded for the whole class? I feel a similar principle applies, here. Maybe you look fabulous in your lace-up vinyl leggings—I’m sure you do, dear—but the vast majority of people are, to put it kindly, not flattered by leather pants. I once arrived at an internship to see my middle-aged supervisor wearing a pair (with a sweater set) and I’m pretty sure that constituted a Hostile Work Environment, which is illegal.

2. NON-NECESSITY-BASED SHORTS

Mischa Barton leggy in denim shorts filming a reality show in LA5 All I Want for Christmas is for You to Stop Wearing That

You know who needs shorts? Camp counselors. Children in the summer. Parents chasing after children in the summer. People in untenably hot weather (this is why I would recommend a temperature-related exemption—the exact details of which, like at what degree the exemption takes effect, will take some further thought). I understand that sometimes it is just too hot for pants, and while part of me is of the opinion that this is a sign that you should stay indoors where it is air-conditioned, and another part of me would like to suggest a nice sundress, a third part of me has a toddler, and understands that children need to get out of the house even if it IS pushing 90, and playgrounds demand attire that prevents sand introducing itself to your undercarriage.

But FORMAL SHORTS? Shorts in the WINTER? Shorts when so many other options, like PANTS, would suffice?
NO. No. Short shorts often hit you at your widest part; longer shorts make you look like a stumpy Ranger Rick. Look at Mischa Barton up there! She looks like someone spliced her top half onto the bottom half of my elementary school gym teacher.

No. It will not stand. Not in shorts, at least.

3. NON-NECESSITY-BASED BOOTS

When I am huddled by my radiator on a day with windchills in the range of 30 below, my car invisible under a hump of snow, and I see a picture of some demi-famous twat in LA simpering out of Kitson in shearling boots and a TANK TOP…it…it…something threatens to snap inside of me.

One day it WILL snap, and I won’t be responsible for the consequences.

miley uggs 525x721 All I Want for Christmas is for You to Stop Wearing That

Miley, this means you. No one is above the law.

4. SACK WEAR

I do not think this means what you think it means. What it means is clothing that is marketed almost exclusively to people on whom it would be massively unflattering. Think Eileen Fisher or J.Jill, think swaths of burlap/raw silk with yardage more appropriate to duvet covers than to a garment, even if you ARE calling that garment “The Sunday Morning Tunic.”

 All I Want for Christmas is for You to Stop Wearing That

Catalogs are frequent targets of my ire, and the catalogs for clothing like this inevitably feature lanky, six-foot-three models. Frankly, even they do not always look their best in these outfits, but they still look beautiful because, you know, they’re models. However then some poor woman built more like, well, me, sees the picture.

“Hey!” she thinks, “That looks so pretty (on her)! And comfortable!” The next thing you know, said woman’s wearing some shin-length “dune” colored caftan with seaglass buttons and resembling nothing more than a sad clown, when she could have looked perfectly ravishing if only someone had steered her toward a nice wrap dress and a fitted cardigan.

I could go on (turtlenecks under sweatshirts! GOD!), but maybe I shouldn’t take up all of Santa’s time. Would you like to add a few list items of your own?

Go ahead, don’t be shy. Santa’s listening.

About Alexa Stevenson

When she isn’t teaching her two-year-old to chant “DONNA MARTIN GRADUATES,” Alexa can be found writing online at Flotsam, working on her second book (her first, Half Baked, was published in August 2010), or squinching her eyes shut in the hopes that when they reopen she she will find herself transported to the picturesque hamlet of Stars Hollow. No luck so far.


Subscribe to MamaPop


(Advertisement)

  • http://fawnlikeadeer.blogspot.com Fawn Amber

    Damn Mischa….are you intentionally trying to look like you’ve put on weight???

  • http://yesimadethat.blogspot.com Lori

    As someone who lives in a climate where knit hats (known as “toques”) are necessary for WARMTH and for NOT DYING in the winter I have a huge aversion to anyone wearing knit hats when it’s not for warmth. Especially those perched (magically!) on the back of the head where they just sort of hang there (how?) and don’t provide any life-saving warmth to the ears or forehead.

    • Shannon

      THIS. Ugh.

  • Suzy Q

    Formal shorts. NO.

    Miley looks totally wasted in that photo. Good image choice.

  • Kel P.

    The boots with tank top/shorts/summer clothing are one of my biggest pet peeves.

    Do they have some sort of medical condition that causes insanely cold feet even in extreme heat?

  • http://www.agirlandaboy.com/journal agirlandaboy

    Stirrup pants. We did it once, and I thought we’d learned our lesson, but NO.

    • http://yesimadethat.blogspot.com Lori

      A hearty “Amen” to this one

  • http://issascrazyworld.com Issa

    YES on the boots. Uggs in July are insane. It should be outlawed.

  • JellyBean

    Can we add Ed Hardy items to the list? Overdone, overkill, just over. Even my nail lady wears a Ed Hardy apron. What’s next? Ed Hardy oven mitts?

  • bd

    Jeggings and boots with open toes. I can’t believe I knew that “jean leggings” are called jeggings. *bangs head on desk*

  • http://www.meangirlgarage.com jules

    *Putting faux leather pants into Goodwill bag now*

    Sigh

  • JB

    “Pushing 90″ is OMG HOT for you? Where do you live, so I can move there? “Pushing 90″ is “wow what a nice cool day” in Texas.

    Can we add jeggings and skinny jeans to this list?

    • http://rachathi.blogspot.com Rachel

      I was thinking the same thing about the “pushing 90 degrees” statement!! I gotta say, I really love the 70 degree day we had today though…

  • http://raisingzoeyjane.com Zoeyjane

    Okay, those shapeless suede, shearling-lined boots that actually existed as slippers and moisturizing pedi boots – but are now worn by celebs with shorts – need to go. And they especially need to disappear from my neighbourhood, where I get to witness “fashion-forward” moms combining them with over-taxed yoga pants and wool peacoats. wtf?

    • http://yezelbelle.wordpress.com/ Yezelbelle

      My biggest issue (while living in the tundra of the midwest) is people wearing them DURING THE SUMMER! I sort of understand wearing them while in the winter to keep the tootsies warm but that being said, what the frick – full, fleece lined boots in summer? Can we say hot and smelly? Ewww.

      • Holly

        Yes! When I see that I always think, her feet must *really* stink. Wait ’til she takes those off. ugh.

  • http://www.serendipityofasymington.blogspot.com Serendipity

    I saw a stand for Jeggings in the mall today and it startled me into a “WTF?!”, whereupon I received a dirty look from the Customer Service ladies. But seriously. Jeggings? Where the hell is that a good idea?

    • jacki

      Jeggings are only a good idea when Conan O’Brien decides to wear them for a whole episode because Tim Gunn taunted him with, “You could wear them, but *should* you?”

  • http://everydayjillwentupthehill.blogspot.com/ everydayjill

    I agree wholeheartedly with all of this but especially with the Eileen Fisher/J Jill catalogue fails. They always make everything sound so enticing and beautiful. Unfortunately, they can put seaglass buttons on a sack and it is still a sack.

  • Mike

    Okay yes, but there needs to be a boot exception for boots with miniskirts because that is just too hott (on girls, anyway) to be banned. Sorry if it seems wrong, but it is so. And, unlike burlap, it is not hot only on 6’3″ stick-like models with big boobs.

    • Mike

      …though the exception does not apply to uggs and things that look like them. those should die.

    • http://www.missmooseart.com Lis

      I agree. Boots + Miniskirts = Win. Though the boots may only be made of leather or a leather-lookalike material. I saw a girl this week (in Michigan. When it was 8F.) wearing a miniskirt and what appears to be cable-knit boots. It was sad. If you’re dressing that much for comfort of your toes, ditch the sexy skirt.

  • http://swanfeet.wordpress.com/ ladyphlogiston

    Knitted ponchos. I’m not up enough to know if they’re really a thing, but there’s several women in my synagogue who wear them, and…no. just no. I can (sorta) understand grabbing one instead of a jacket or coat, but wearing it as part of your outfit is just terrible.

    (This goes triple for the lady who wears hers over her baby carrier, I guess while the baby is asleep. I’m sure it’s a lovely warm snuggly arrangement, but it looks awful and you’re in a semi-formal public setting. And I’ve seen the baby sleeping without so I don’t think she does it out of necessity.)

  • http://www.missmooseart.com Lis

    Neon pants. Bonus if they are leggings. And/or shiny.

  • DianaCLT

    Hate jeggings. HATE. And cannot comprehend skinny cargo pants (Old Navy, I’m looking at YOU). If skinny pants are intended to look skinny…and cargo pants are intended to be baggy…WTF does it mean to put them together?

    “Look at me! I’m skinny enough for skinny pants, but want to intentionally give myself that saddlebag appearance!”

    Big oops!!!: I was ripping on jeggings one day, only to learn that one of my friends has a few pairs. And LOVES them. I back-pedaled a bit, and then said, “Oh, I didn’t mean JEGGINGS, I meant those awful SKINNY CARGO PANTS.” To which my other friend said…”I have those…” Yeah. I felt like an asshat. Only salvation was pointing out that her (built-like-a-5-year-old) boyish figure was THE ONLY figure that would work for them – and ‘Oh, how I wish I could pull off that look!’

    (NOTTTTT!!!!!)