Jive Turkey’s Guilty Pleasure: Menopausal Romantic Comedies

Internet: prepare to lose the rest of your respect for me…assuming there’s any left.

Steve Guttenberg Jive Turkeys Guilty Pleasure: Menopausal Romantic Comedies

I am, after all, the woman who nursed a pretty serious adolescent crush on one Steven Guttenberg.

(My apologies to your sex drive for the exposure to this photograph.)

I have some pretty embarrassing guilty pleasures (…obviously), so I could have taken the easy way out when writing this post and told you about my love of Intervention-type shows (the more self-destruction, the better!), my unhealthy attachment to the first season of 16 and Pregnant, or my unabashed attraction to any and all nature documentaries filmed in HD with narration by Sigourney Weaver and/or Oprah.

Sunrise Earth 580x326 Jive Turkeys Guilty Pleasure: Menopausal Romantic Comedies

I have also been known to watch entire, narration-less episodes of Sunrise Earth. Know what that is? ONE WHOLE HOUR OF THE SUN RISING. It’s all hookers and blow at my house, folks.

Discussing all of those somewhat run-of-the-mill guilty pleasures, however, seemed pretty safe to me.  I needed to dig up some serious dirt for this post, Internet, and that is why I chose to share with you my love (and shamefully repeated viewing) of romantic comedies with solidly middle-aged casts.

AlecBaldwin 580x797 Jive Turkeys Guilty Pleasure: Menopausal Romantic Comedies

I’ll have one aging Alec Baldwin, please. The puffier the better.

The thing is? I don’t even like romantic comedies. I mean, sure, I’ve been known to waste 108 precious minutes of my life (plus commercials!) watching Sweet Home Alabama on TBS while I fold laundry or paint my nails or whatnot, but I will not pay CASH MONEY to view anything starring Katherine Heigl or Ginnifer Goodwin, and if I was given the choice of either gouging my eyes out or having to watch He’s Just Not That Into You again?

Oedipus Jive Turkeys Guilty Pleasure: Menopausal Romantic ComediesI’m feelin’ ya, Oedipus.

WHY IS IT, then, that I have such an incredible weakness when it comes to romantic comedies involving characters over age 40 and beyond? Because, my friends, if you give me a quiet night at home with a bottle of red wine and some Viagra-humor-infused boning queued up on the DVR? I am one happy lady. One happy, pathetic, not-getting-laid-anytime-soon lady.

Bored Couple Jive Turkeys Guilty Pleasure: Menopausal Romantic Comedies

Apparently Diane Keaton’s finest work isn’t considered foreplay? Whatever, husband.

Oh, but we’re not done yet! I have yet to share my top three favorite mid-life rom-coms, ranked in order from most socially acceptable to most horrifically damaging to my reputation and marriage:

1. Something’s Gotta Give: This little number was my gateway drug into the 60s R&B-soundtracked world of middle-aged cinema. Even if you’re not into this genre, you have to admit this movie is pretty solid. It garnered quite a few awards and nominations, and earned Diane Keaton a Golden Globe and an Oscar for her earnest and touching portrayal as divorced playwright Erica Barry. I am always unpleasantly surprised by the appearance of Keanu Reeves in this movie, and I’ve never been Jack Nicholson’s biggest fan (since when is SQUINTING equivalent to ACTING?!), but dammit if I don’t watch this particular picture show every time it’s on TV.

Somethings Gotta Give 580x386 Jive Turkeys Guilty Pleasure: Menopausal Romantic Comedies

My 62-year-old mother and I once bonded over the fact that we both really like this movie, so…yeah. That about says it all.

2. It’s Complicated: Actually, no, it’s not: this movie is pretty lame, and so am I for actually ENJOYING IT. Sure, it’s got Alec Baldwin, Steve Martin and Meryl Streep (and John Krasinski, if that’s your thing) (it’s not mine), but still: LAME. I’ve discovered that I am not a fan of Alec Baldwin sans Jack Donaghy or Steve Martin sans banjo/wacky hijinks or Meryl Streep sans, well, A DECENT SCRIPT, but I’ll sure as shit watch this movie whenever it airs on HBO (which has been a lot lately, like, THANKS, HBO, for enabling my slow descent into dried up crusty old crone-hood).

Its Complicated 580x386 Jive Turkeys Guilty Pleasure: Menopausal Romantic Comedies

Although this scene is kind of endearing because Meryl Streep is so charming and DAMMIT! It’s happening again! Someone help me!

 

OK. All better.

3. Because I Said So: Oh, you guys. I know, I KNOW, I know I’ve disappointed you so far, but this is really going to hurt. Have you ever seen this movie? It’s painful beyond compare. What’s worse is that I actually ordered this movie via Netflix streaming one night when I was home alone. Yes, that’s right: I paid actual American dollars for this experience. Not even Diane Keaton can save this movie from itself, such is the awesome power of its deeply awkward writing and acting. Also? The middle-aged love interest in this one? Is the Dad from 7th Heaven. I mean, no offense against that guy, but…OK, offense against that guy. He gives me the creeps and I can’t stand his hair. Suffice it to say, the entire project just a complete clusterfuck of horrible from beginning to end, and yet: I WATCH. AND I WATCH. AND I WATCH.

Because I Said So 580x362 Jive Turkeys Guilty Pleasure: Menopausal Romantic Comedies

And I cringe at Diane Keaton’s weird Transitions lenses AND I WATCH.

OK. We’re done. I’m sorry. Don’t look at me, I’m hideous!

The Elephant Man 580x434 Jive Turkeys Guilty Pleasure: Menopausal Romantic Comedies

This is not the Elephant Man. It’s a photo of me watching Must Love Dogs.

About Jive Turkey

Jive Turkey lives in Pittsburgh and spends her time desperately clinging to the hope that someday the cast of Deadwood will destroy the cast of Glee.


Subscribe to MamaPop


(Advertisement)

  • http://mytornadoalley.com Jen O.

    That picture of Alec must be old. I don’t remember the last time a) we could see his neck or b) he could put his arms flat down at his side.

    (psst – Something’s Gotta Give is pretty much the most awesomest movie that ever awesomed)

    • http://jiveturkeyjives.com/ Jive Turkey

      Bless you.

  • Shawn

    I am right there with you sister. I assure you I am a man I just have a penchant for RomComs. (Feel free to take away my man card for using RomCom and penchant in the same sentence.)

    Oh, neverrmind. You jumped the tracks, crashed the bus, light fire to the nursery filled with baby bunnies and just plain poo-pooed all over my respect for you with that last one. Dear sweet baby Jesus that was a terrible movie. I don’t even think I finished it and I have a serious crush on what’s-her-butt from the ‘Gilmore Girls’. So shame on you. For shame.

    Now I’m going to go down thirty margaritas at happy hour and go home (sans baby and girlfriend) and fire up It’s Complicated and have a good cry.

  • Katie

    I heart Somethings Gotta Give, too. The title, eh…not so much.

  • http://txtingmrdarcy.wordpress.com Txtingmrdarcy

    I think that we should be friends. Because all of your guilty pleasures? I share. Including Sunrise Earth.

    *hides face in shame*

  • Gaby

    I could watch “Something’s Gotta Give” purely for the house porn. Her kitchen! Her bedroom! I want a beautiful, East coast summer home! The story is ok, but the HOUUUUUSE. *sigh*

    • http://www.oncemore.typepad.com JenfromBoston

      Me and my husband watch this movie for that house, too! The house should get a movie credit, seriously.

  • http://mytornadoalley.com Jen O.

    ALSO! ALSO!!! AS GOOD AS IT GETS!!! I think I love that one the best.

  • Suzy Q

    I love nature documentaries, too, especially ocean-y ones. So, you get both a pass and a high-five for that. I would even watch that sunrise one because I am a Nature Dork.

    But! But, I cannot forgive Because I Said So. That movie is absolute dreck. Diane Keaton was SO annoying in it and it was SO STUPID.

    However, I have a thing for Alec Baldwin, so a point in your favor. And, so help me, I like romcoms, too.

  • helenel

    Oh! Must Love Dogs! I’d forgotten about that one! Thanks!

  • Mona

    There is no shame in loving Something’s Got to Give- it is a pretty darn decent movie. Because the Diane Keaton- she is fabulous. She looks better now than she did 30 years ago and she is charming and self depricating and smart and we should all big time heart her and any movie that showcases her as the prime love interest – in all her post 50 glory. Love!
    That said, I have not seen Because I Said So, and probably shouldn’t.

  • http://mommyblogyay.blogspot.com Renee

    These movies are the equivalent of smooth jazz. Which I just can’t do yet. Call me when Steve Guttenberg stars in one.

  • http://www.blog.brandibphotography.net Brandi

    I’m ashamed to admit Because I Said So is a total guilty pleasure of mine. Mandy Moore is a total slut! Diane Keaton is horrible! Lauren Graham is barely in it. But I have a major crush on the single dad/guitar player guy. I can’t quit you, actor I don’t know!

  • http://www.herecomesthegrump.wordpress.com Lis

    I….um…I have seen all the movies you speak of here…I….um.. *own* Must Love Dogs*…I can’t help it, aging John Cusack pretty much makes me weak in the knees and I understand that admitting to owning this means I have to relinquish my Motorhead t-shirt but I AM NOT GOING TO.

    *In my defense, it was one of 5 for $20 used at blockbuster**….

    **I may watch it tonight as I edit pictures and drink my white wine with ice because I am THAT much of a rock star.