Jenny McCarthy Is 39, A Mother, And Posing Naked In ‘Playboy’—Why Do We Care?


Jenny McCarthy is Playboy‘s latest cover girl. Her seventh Playboy front cover—featuring the 39-year-old actress/model/host/mama clad in fingerless gloves and, well, her birthday suit—hit the newsstands on June 29th.

 Jenny McCarthy Is 39, A Mother, And Posing Naked In Playboy—Why Do We Care?

How wonderful for her. Honestly, I didn’t really think much of it until I started seeing all the media headlines.

She’s a mom! She’s 39!

People magazine says, “just months away from hitting the big 4-0, Jenny proves she’s still got it.” Imagine! It’s a miracle!

Interesting. The media is shocked that a 39-year-old woman can be sexy. Really? Have they taken a look at Kate Beckinsale lately? Or Jennifer Lopez? The media feels the need to come out with studies to prove that moms still want to have sex. Well, here’s where I send the media into a frenzy. I am 34 years old. I am the mother to three young children. I have sex every day. Because I like it; because I am sexy.

But then I wonder…are we perpetuating the insinuation that women over a certain age don’t like sex? A very dear friend, on a recent Facebook status, wrote the following: Husbands are happy the day after sex because, duh. Wives are happy because we have at least a few days off before the begging starts again.

Many, many women “liked” her status—over 25, in fact. And I get it—I really, really do. They are tired, they have young children, they are super busy, they consider sex to be somewhat of a chore. Yet, while I recognize that I may be more of an exception to a rule, are we sending men (and the media) the wrong message? Are we allowing people to be shocked when 39-year-old moms consider themselves to be sexy and continue to enjoy having sex? Are we allowing people to dump on women like Jenny McCarthy?

 Jenny McCarthy Is 39, A Mother, And Posing Naked In Playboy—Why Do We Care?

An article in Salon tried to say that McCarthy truly isn’t representative of “the norm” and that she is creating a sort of false tale of what it’s like to be almost 40. According to the article, “..acting like it’s no big deal that McCarthy still looks that way at her age. Of course, some people have incredible metabolisms, but it’s just disingenuous to act like it does not take a load of money for trainers, gym memberships, doctor check-ups, proper workout shoes, and the like, as well as time. To work out for hours every day while maintaining a career and being a mother to a 10-year-old is unrealistic for most women.”

But here’s what I don’t understand. I can’t afford a gym membership, so I ride my bike—when I can fit it into my schedule between work and driving carpool and swimming lessons. I watch what I eat pretty regularly, but I certainly can’t afford to have someone cook my meals for me. Yes, of course Jenny McCarthy’s lifestyle is not really the case for most people.

But so what?

I am still sexy. I have inches on my body that I can pinch. I have boobs that absolutely need to be held up by a great-fitting brassiere. I have stretch marks that have turned silver over time. I don’t understand where it says that we have to look exactly like she does to consider ourselves sexy, or to have other people think we are sexy.

Jenny McCarthy isn’t defining sexy at 39. She isn’t defining sexy for mothers. She isn’t putting pressure on you or me or anyone else. She is just embracing it—what’s wrong with that?

Salon goes on to take issue with Jenny McCarthy’s “salute to the MILFS,” which in reality is basically saying that they take issue with the objectification of women at any age, really. The author seems to be put-off by the entire concept of Playboy magazine and the industry as a whole. It doesn’t matter that McCarthy is 39 or a mom—the author is upset that this is diminishing women.

I guess what I’m saying is, while the backlash from this cover spread was inevitable (and we all know that it was), why is it necessary? Why do people care so much? Are people bothered that she is 39? Are people bothered that she is a mom? Are they bothered that she feels that she is sexy? Or are the bothered by the mere fact that she is posing nude—regardless of age, parental status, or sex-factor?

Can’t she *just* be a woman who posed for Playboy?

About Ali Martell

When Ali isn't writing her Seinfeld-esque drivel over at her personal site, Cheaper Than Therapy, or writing about fashion on her YummyMummyClub.ca blog From Hemlines to Heels, she is giving Buffy the Vampire Slayer a chance, laughing maniacally at the absurdity of 50 Shades of Grey, and trying to stop the world from wearing leggings as pants.



From Our Partners

  • Tyskkvinna

    I have a general, free-range hatred for Jenny McCarthy, but it’s got nothing to do with her age, her motherhood status or whether or not she poses nude in Playboy.

    I read an article in some magazine fairly recently, written by Roseanne. She spoke about how she is past menopause now, and has zero interest in sex, or feeling sexy, or anything in that realm. And how she was happy about it, she felt relief. She felt she could focus on the things she has needed to do all along but couldn’t because she was busy being sexy.

    It annoyed me. I mean, yay for Roseanne that she chose to ignore sex completely and she feels better for it. It’s her prerogative. But boo for perpetrating the mindset that as soon as women reach “a certain age” she is going to turn off the sex switch entirely. It feels like people are just waiting for every woman to reach that point and get “on with other things”. Whereas, of course, men can still be roarin’ to go well into their 90s and it’s okay.

    • alimartell

      Ha. Oh yes. I didn’t get into how I personally feel about her (which is, um, OMG I CANNOT STAND HER) but like you said…it has nothing to do with her age or her motherhood status.

    • http://www.facebook.com/people/Amy-Corlett/1097844595 Amy Corlett

      Sorry if this runs in the face of what this post is about. But, ummm, wait. Roseanne was busy being sexy?

      • http://www.facebook.com/people/Amy-Corlett/1097844595 Amy Corlett

        But seriously, I think Roseanne’s comments – on top of the craze over Jenny McCarthy’s 39 year old sexiness (shock!) – make me wonder if many women feel such pressure to “be sexy” or “feel sexy” or enjoy sex, that when they reach an age, they feel like they are allowed to not comform to that anymore. It makes me think of holding your tummy in all day at work, and the relief of getting home and just being who you’ve been all along. Maybe too many are faking the sexy to meet some standard, rather than just allowing themselves to feel it or not feel it organically. The idea of sexy begins to have a negative connotation for some because they’ve been pressured to exaggerate their sexiness? Maybe?

  • http://twitter.com/allisonzapata Allison Zapata

    Love it. You know, it’s not so much that I don’t love sex, or feel sexy, because I do. (the feeling sexy is just coming back after baby number 2 and the depression that came with it), but more than anything, it’s that my husband and I seem to be on different horny schedules. Ha. He is ready at night, after dinner, after the kids are in bed, etc. I am ready in the morning, as he is rushing out the door to work. I guess both of us need to bend a little to meet each other, huh? Great post, Ali. xo

    • alimartell

      I’m so happy you read this. That status has been on my mind TONS since you posted it. Because I SO SO SO get it…I have been there. I had wee ones that were close in age…

      I just don’t want the media to be allowed to think that’s the norm…that women are uninterested after babies and as we age…because then women start to believe it too. If that makes sense?

      • http://twitter.com/GingerBecc Ginger Snaps

        It makes total sense. If people hear something over & over again they start to believe that it’s truth, regardless of it’s accuracy or veracity (that’s why Fox News is so effective.) For our part as women we somehow choose, those of us who do, to buy into the notion that “after 40 we do this” or “can’t do this after a certain age.” A lot of people’s notions are formed out of their own hang-ups; why should we make that our problem? *throw your hands up at meh*

      • http://twitter.com/allisonzapata Allison Zapata

        I totally get it. TOTALLY. And tonight, I am having sex, FOR YOU.

        Wait. This just got weird, didn’t it? :)

  • http://twitter.com/GingerBecc Ginger Snaps

    I’m not a huge fan of hers either, but at least she’s not afraid to show she’s human. She was very public about her pregnancy weight (something like 60+ lbs.) & how she worked her but off to lose it, not by getting plastic surgery. Maybe this is thinking too deep but perhaps it makes some guys uncomfortable to think about over 40 women being sexy because it reminds them of their moms *gasp- moms have sex??* or it reminds them that their attraction to women in their 20′s gets a little creepy when the guy himself hits 40 and over. Who knows.

  • rageagainsttheminivan

    I think this post is missing the reason it’s bothersome to me (and I assume, to others): she has a son, not to far away from an age where his friends will be ogling said magazine. Be sexy . . . yes! But be sexy in private, instead of becoming the masturbatory fodder in a magazine popular with adolescent boys.

    • rageagainsttheminivan

      (I don’t mean that women can’t be sexy in general . . . I’m speaking about showing off ALL OF THE PARTS in a photo that is clearly meant for the gratification of other people’s sexual fantasy, I cannot even imagine how mortified my son would be if I did that.)