What Celebrity Breastfeeding Advocates Can Do Better


Whipping out your above-ground lady parts has never been cooler.  Breastfeeding has swept Hollywood, from Alanis to Alicia.  From Beyonce to Blossom.

mayim bialik family breast feeding What Celebrity Breastfeeding Advocates Can Do Better

Joey says, “Whoa.”

Well, good on ya, celebrity moms.  You have clearly been exposed to science-y know-how about breastmilk’s documented benefit to babies’ development, immunity, and lifelong health (lower instances of diabetes, obesity, and more).  The moms also benefit, whether it be from increased postpartum weight loss or reduction of breast cancer risk.

Kudos, celeb mommies.  In advocating breastfeeding, you are leveraging your relative luxury for good.  Flexible work schedules, financial resources, and large support systems all help a mother succeed in nursing her child longer.

And, all hail celeb mommies.  You are elevating the profile of breastfeeding, an age-old practice that is viewed by many as awkward and antiquated.   Some might say, Celebrity Breastfeeding Mommy Goddess, your work here is done.  I’d say:  keep your shirt on. I don’t mean it like that…I mean, slow down.  Being a role model is a great step.   A great first step.  But there are two big things…

Jessica  Simpson 8 What Celebrity Breastfeeding Advocates Can Do Better

Eyes up here, mind out of the gutter.

…that celebrity breastfeeding cheerleaders….

oregon cheerleaders ABOO0284 590x422 What Celebrity Breastfeeding Advocates Can Do Better

I don’t even understand your sick mind sometimes.

…can do to truly advance a key public health issue in this country. The first is expensive but easy: throw your weight (and your wallet) around.  Breastfeeding may not require you to buy bottles or formula, but it ain’t free.  It requires time, if you work or ever leave your child’s side; it requires expensive equipment, including but not limited to a breast pump.  It requires safe space and an employer who will and can allow you release time to pump those suckers dry or feed your child.

BreastisBestor What Celebrity Breastfeeding Advocates Can Do Better

And all the hours spent wondering, “What is he thinking?”

You’re a brilliant, charming MamaPop reader so I probably don’t have to tell you that all of these costs–monetary and non–can make breastfeeding an issue of socioeconomic equity.  If you are over 30, upwardly mobile, have a salaried job, have access to support, and two white boobs, you’re more likely to be able to breastfeed.  If you’re younger, have a lower income, and are Latino or African American, you’re less likely to breastfeed.  And thanks to some seriously broken systems, inequity begets inequity: race and class impact your educational opportunity, employment prospects, etc…which impact your likelihood to be able to breastfeed.

So if celebs used their dollars and ability to get an audience on Capitol Hill to promote educational and employment opportunities for all women, we’d be getting somewhere.  If celebs used their influence to elevate the need for greater employer cooperation in supporting nursing moms, we’d be in boobtastic business.

Hooters 590x442 What Celebrity Breastfeeding Advocates Can Do Better

Don’t be such a literalist.

So I mentioned a second thing celebs could do:  strike back at free shit.

Across America, cities and states are asking hospitals to stop giving out free formula swag bags to new mommies and focus on advocating that more new moms nurse.  They are doing it to address burgeoning childhood obesity rates, healthcare costs, diabetes raining from the sky in sweet, sweet buckets…you name it.  But they see a correlation between the number of women receiving formula swag and women’s commitment to breastfeeding (or, even, to buying other brands of formula).  and too many hospitals don’t have the resources to give up the revenue from swag-y relationships.  Free stuff is a powerful thing…celebs know it better than anyone.   What if breastfeeding celebs launched a “No Similac Swag Bags Or I Won’t Show My Gladbags” campaign?  Damn straight, some hospitals and companies would listen.

I’ll confess that I’m uncomfortable banning most anything.  And I’m even more loathe to question ANYONE’S choice to breastfeed or not.  Breastfeeding is so, so hard.  I did it for 11 months, I was bad at it, it was awful…and I’m so lucky to have been able to do it.  But I’m more uncomfortable with perpetuating inequity by not helping more women access a wider array of choices, by going straight to free stuff without providing an array of options.  And while I don’t like even suggesting that women don’t know what they want without a menu, I feel like this conversation hasn’t progressed to the point where we don’t know what we (or they) don’t know.  And I’m most uncomfortable with an uneven playing field.  I have a feeling that many of the biggest stars–especially those with a wriggling creature dangling from their nipples–might just be uncomfortable with that, too.

source, source, source, source

About Molly Martin

Molly lives and works in Indianapolis, primarily because of her rabid devotion to "One Day at a Time." Continues to lobby city leaders to change city slogan to "Dammit, Julie!"



From Our Partners

  • B

    I really don’t understand this anti- free formula in hospitals thing. Can’t you advocate breastfeeding AND have formula available for those who want/need it? Plus, it’s not like they’re offering free formula for life. A reasonably intelligent woman isn’t going to make a decision based on a short-term supply of free stuff. If you do have good research that free formula leading to less breastfeeding thing, I would be happy to see it. But it just seems like unnecessary shaming of formula-users to me.

    • MollyGMartin

      No, you’re right: it shouldn’t be about shaming people. I worry about this option not even being presented as feasible or being enabled among lower income women. But, yeah…I go ’round in circles. Some states claim data on buying patterns associated with formula samples but i’ve seen nothing that would knock any of our socks off… Really pleased you chimed in.

    • anna

      In the hospitals that do not give out the free formula swag, there is still formula available. The formula hasn’t left the hospital, but the mother must simply request it. and even the bf mom’s can request formula. Before, you were basically giving every single person a formula bag weather they wanted it or not. An analogy would be the grocery store loading every single customer who walked in the door with a hamburger. Even if you don’t eat hamburgers. What if you wanted chicken that night. But you have this free hamburger…

      To add fuel to the fire, in many hospitals if a bf mother requests formula she must then sign consent for the formula. That has also been a point of concern. But even the most reasonably intelligent woman, after days of laboring, and then days of a crying baby, who won’t latch, and her nipples are falling off might not be at her most reasonable or intelligent. in that sleep depraved state, would you even remember asking for formula? Did you know that if that poor nurse who was just trying to help you be sued for assault and battery on your infant because she “unknowingly” gave your child formula?
      I am in no way wanting to shame anyone making the choice to formula feed. But the swag bags ARE impacting breastfeeding. go to http://www.banthebags.org for some more info.

      • Tyskkvinna

        I’ve heard SO many mixed stories from mothers and their hospital experience that I have a hard time believe sweeping statements about this. Some had formula shoved into their stuff as they leave, some had to beg for it.

  • Shanen

    Being the mother of two children one 3 and one 6 mos and I’m still nursing my 6 mos. I know how easy it is at the beginning to give up on bf and use formula. Bf is ape sh!t hard. Formula is easy and painless. The only formula my baby got was given to me in a swag bag. And thankfully this time around I pushed through the pain and the constantly being attached to something whether being baby or pump. It’s easy to give up especially being so tired on top of it all. I know first hand how convienent formula is in the first 6 weeks. Those swag bags are the reason I had formula in the house at all.

    • MollyGMartin

      Same here — I had to hide the free bottles (WHICH I TOTALLY KEPT) to keep from quitting. The mix of reactions here brings one thing into focus: if you go in having opted to BF, you probably need a different set of options.

  • http://twitter.com/ladyjess78 Jessi Jump

    The anti-formula shaming is a really touchy subject with me. I had a particularly hard time of it (once being told that my child should be placed in foster care since I was feeding her poison) and I just… I just can’t condone anything that makes a mom feel like less for a healthy decision. Yes, bottle-feeding may not be ideal. But for some moms, myself included, it’s the best decision for us. Taking away these “swag bags” with their small formula samples makes it harder to find what works. (And I am speaking for those who know they are going to formula feed and need to try multiple brands, not for those who are gung-ho about breastfeeding or even those who are on the fence.) It also puts a completely valid choice further into the realm of “not acceptable.”

    I guess I don’t understand the reason behind this. When my youngest was born, I had to print a certificate and take it to the hospital to get my bag because they were trying to make it less accessible. Then I had to listen to the insufferable lecturing of a nurse and turn down a lactation consultant 22 times. There is advocating for what you believe and then there is taking it a step too far.

    • MollyGMartin

      The flip side is of formula advocacy can be just as wacky, for SURE. No one, no one, no one made me feel worse than lactation consultants over the phone. I like your point about leaving people to their own devices instead of giving them a way to find a product that works for them. And it’s interesting that in NYC the soft drink ban-types and the swag bag ban movement are united…when both groups probably endorse McDonald’s posting calorie details so people can make their own decisions. Thanks for sharing your thoughts! I appreciate it.

      • Tyskkvinna

        I think most problems in the world could be repaired of severely decreased if we ramped up education (posting calories, giving new mothers USEFUL information, are only little examples)… funny how that works.

        • MollyGMartin

          The More You Know *ding*

  • Tyskkvinna

    I would like to see some of the pro-breastmilk companies come up with some swag. I know pumps are expensive, but there’s got to be some other things they could give out to help compete in this game. Seems like the most reasonable way to fight this consumerism fight, eh?

    • MollyGMartin

      Interesting! It really is a big product placement game on all sides, right?

  • MollyGMartin

    *chastened* True :) I have never been able to talk myself in guilty circles with more aplomb than after becoming a mother!