X-Factor’s Soul Crushing Reunion: Emotional Discomfort Makes The Ratings Go ‘Round


I hated Meet The Parents. Watching people embarrass themselves gives me the trots, so I’d like to thank The X-Factor for the fifteen pounds I undoubtedly lost after watching the world’s most horrifically uncomfortable competition show audition OF. ALL. TIME.

I missed X-Factor last season, but you KNOW I wasn’t going to miss Britney Spears‘s debut on the show, so I tuned in eager-as-hell last night. (And by the way, when did Simon Cowell get so much work done, and why can’t he recognize the total lack of talent in his own plastic surgeon?) If you’re not following the show, it’s basically American Idol in an amphitheater with a massive audience and full band from day one.  Instead of Randy Jackson you have L.A. Reid, and instead of Paula Abdul/Her-Neverending-List-of-Replacements you have Britney Spears and Demi Lovato. And then there’s Simon Cowell as himself.

So last night, following a very impressive post-boy-band-neo-beastie-boy-band type group performed their own original tune that was kind of catchy, a dude named Don Philip took the stage. Britney recognized him immediately, and his “package” revealed that the two had duet’d on the tune “I Will Still Love You” off of Brit’s first album.

DonBrit 590x324 X Factors Soul Crushing Reunion: Emotional Discomfort Makes The Ratings Go Round

Don Philip and Brit Brit in less soul-crushing times.

Let the awkward begin. When Simon asked him what he’s been doing since, the dude broke down in tears and rambled for a while before commencing an off-key performance that made Britney look like she might, I dunno…SHAVE HER HEAD. But it was after he got his four resounding “NOs” that things really started to make me want to peel my own face off to escape the discomfort.

See for yourself:

Why does reality TV do this to us? There were points in last night’s show that were so uncomfortable to watch that I felt like Cowell and Co. were playing their own little game of Emotional Gladiator.

Don Phlip X Factors Soul Crushing Reunion: Emotional Discomfort Makes The Ratings Go Round

Yeah, Don Philip, we’re embarrassed too.

And lest ye forget how awkward it was on The Voice last season when Xtina failed to recognize former Mickey Mouse Club co-star Tonny Lucca, launching a feud that would last the entire season and potentially cost Lucca the title? It’s like they take our worst nightmares about our high school reunions and play them out in prime time. BUT THEN BRITNEY SPEARS IS JUST SO WEIRD I CAN’T NOT WATCH HER. Oh the humanity.

clockwork X Factors Soul Crushing Reunion: Emotional Discomfort Makes The Ratings Go Round

Me watching X-Factor.

Did you catch The X-Factor? Did it make you want to die?

source, source, source

About The 818

Morgan Shanahan is a professional blogger and screenwriter living in Los Angeles’ San Fernando Valley (aka “The818”) with her toddler daughter, dashing hubby, and farting trio of dogs. In addition to over-sharing her personal life (complete with curse words) on The818.com, she's also BlogHer's Entertainment Editor, and writes occasionally about art and design for Cargoh.com. She also tweets, pins, and instagrams.



From Our Partners

  • http://twitter.com/jennamariebee Mrs. Jenna

    OH MY GOD THE UNCOMFORTABLE. Brit-Brit might want to hire some extra security for the next few days.

  • MollyGMartin

    Zowie! I’m glad I missed it…can I just rely on you to traumatize me secondhand?

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Amy-Corlett/1097844595 Amy Corlett

    I have only seen this clip you’re giving us, but I can’t blame Britney for the uncomfortable. She most likely didn’t know they were going to spring this guy on her. The blame goes to Producers (Cowell?) and more to that guy Don. He’s frozen in time emotionally – those were not the actions of a stable 32 yr old man! He didn’t “hurt” Britney…he put her on the spot & embarassed her. But what he saw in her eyes wasn’t hurt, I think it was pity & discomfort. That was awful and I’m mortified for him most of all.

    • http://twitter.com/the818 Morgan (The818)

      No, totally agree. That’s what was so effing freaky. His freaky regression at the end. Either that, or he was angling for a Razzie.

  • DianaCLT

    I normally pass over reviews of shows I don’t watch. Why, oh why, did I click on this? That was uncomfortable. I was awkwardly squirming watching this, after the fact, at home. WHY did he keep apologizing for hurting her? I don’t get it. It was obvious she was embarrassed and that’s just sad. His voice wasn’t bad, per se. It sounds like a boy band voice. Just a little out-of-date. Ick. Icky Ick Ick ICK.

  • http://www.sweetney.com Sweetney

    I enjoy The Voice. But this? Eeek. Don’t think I’ll be tuning in now, thanks.

  • http://lauriemrauch.com/ Laurie M. Rauch

    I actually found the whole night awkward and uncomfortable… from the entire hour dedicated to flashes over to the mean blonde girls right up to her not that great performance, through the Don Philip debacle, right into the bullied girl tearful performance. I normally love these singing talent shows, but X Factor’s focus on the mean rather than on the singing is probably going to take this off my PVR this season.

  • Snarky_Amber

    This is why I watch The Voice—there’s no humiliation on that show. I can’t take people embarrassing themselves on television for others’ “entertainment.” It does a number on my stomach.

  • GirlWithTheKittenTattoo

    Yes, this was terrible, but I was really moved by the girl who was bullied in school and sang beautifully although she was crying.