Stop Mothering Rihanna About The New Chris Brown Duet


Remember that warm fuzzy feeling you have any time you sing “Islands in the Stream” at karaoke?  The feeling that Kenny Rogers didn’t punch Dolly Parton after the first chorus?

Dolly Kenny 590x393 Stop Mothering Rihanna About The New Chris Brown Duet

“And we let fly on each other – ah ah. Black the eyes of each other – ah ah.”

Yeah, well, hold on to that.  Because Rihanna and her abusive ex-boyfriend Chris Brown‘s duet “Nobody’s Business” won’t leave you feeling so peaceful.

We knew it was coming, the duet with Chris Brown on Rihanna‘s new album Unapologetic.  And, considering the 2011 remix of “Birthday Cake,” it isn’t the first track on which the duo has collaborated since brown’s 2009 arrest and subsequent conviction for assaulting his superstar singer girlfriend.  A plea deal resulted in probation, court-ordered domestic violence counseling, and community service.

But when the new track leaked online yesterday (Nov. 6), the internet indulged in a collective skeeved-out shudder at “Nobody’s Business” lyrics:  ” Our love is perfection, please point me in the right direction.”  ”There’s no other love just like this.”  ”I wanna be your baby, always be your baby.”

Rihanna 590x391 Stop Mothering Rihanna About The New Chris Brown Duet

In her lyrical defense, very few FCC-friendly words rhyme with “FOR THE LOVE OF GOD, DUCK!”

Suddenly, we all wanted to collect Rihanna in our arms, take her home–stopping on the way to snap up Lindsay Lohan–and make her some cocoa, while we all go over a PowerPoint on domestic violence and watch 18 hours of ABC’s After-School Specials.  We wanted to mother her.  Help her.  Hug some sense into her lovely, talented brain.

Dude:  we can’t mother her.  And not in that “lost cause/she doesn’t want our help” way.  In that “we can’t assume she’s not a smart, thoughtful, and grown-up enough business woman to make her own decisions” way.  As MamaPop’s own Kelly so wisely pointed out, Rihanna ”is a grown-ass human woman.”  She didn’t sign on to be our role model or daughter.  She may know or feel something we could never comprehend.

800px Chris Brown 3 590x422 Stop Mothering Rihanna About The New Chris Brown Duet

Like that this is attractive.

And besides: did any of us scoop up Josh Brolin after Diane Lane was accused of battery against him? Nope. When they did the mega-tribute to Glen Campbell at the 2011 [Chris Brown-studded] Grammy awards show, did we march fellow country legend Tanya Tucker onstage to remind everyone that he knocked her around a billion years ago?  No.  So, uh, do we only trust dudes and white women to move beyond the business end of  a police report, Moms of America?  I hope not.

So let’s move on from trying to mother Rihanna every time she utters [or dates or sings with or marries or builds a Play-Doh sculpture of ] Chris Brown.  She’s 24.  She didn’t commit a crime.  She’s a professional.  And she appears to have women in her life to care for her.

Let’s save that maternal energy for more worthwhile targets.  Like our own kids.

Oh and Lindsay Lohan.

AUTHOR’S NOTE:  A few MamaPop Nation friends pointed out I flipped the Brolin-Lane allegations.  Pop cultural recall fail.  Thanks to them!  But I think we can all agree that if we don’t hold other high-profile victims of abuse to constant scrutiny for the next step to healing (and definitely if people move on from constantly mentioning the abuser’s actions), we can lay off Rihanna a bit.

source, source, source, source, source

About Molly Martin

Molly lives and works in Indianapolis, primarily because of her rabid devotion to "One Day at a Time." Continues to lobby city leaders to change city slogan to "Dammit, Julie!"



From Our Partners

  • KellyBDelaney

    Excellent post. While it’s always helpful to have people take the prescribed best courses of action in situations like this that have far-reaching consequences, Rihanna and anyone else dealing with domestic violence is, at the end of the day, an individual who has to determine the best way of living her life with this a part of it. So much of the dialogue thrown at her is just scolding when you get right down to it, which is not really better than diminishing her with abuse, either.

    • MollyGMartin

      “Scolding” — that’s the word I was searching for. And what I was doing mentally. It’s like I wrote this to me.

  • JiveTurkeyJones

    Agreed. Not to mention sometimes I get the feeling she keeps on keepin’ on with Chris Brown just to irritate us. Maybe if we stop paying attention to it, she’ll move on to greener, less punchy pastures?

    • MollyGMartin

      “Less punchy.” *snort*

  • http://twitter.com/Avath Avath

    I’m sorry, I won’t stop thinking this is wrong and wishing she will change her mind. Even if it is judgey of me and she is a Grown Ass Woman and it’s none of my business. If Chris Brown had shown any remorse or growth from the experience at all then maybe this wouldn’t be so wrong in my eyes. But he just tantrums and deflects. I think it’s good we pay attention to it, so other women in this type of situation know that it is wrong.

    • MollyGMartin

      That’s a really good point: making an example of someone…well, it makes an example.

  • http://twitter.com/thegrumbles the grumbles

    she is entirely capable of making her own terrible, moronic decisions. it IS hard to watch though, until you remember you can just turn on the tv and think about something else.

    • MollyGMartin

      Not as hard to watch as ‘Two and a Half Men,’ AMIRITE?!?!

      • SuzyQuzey

        You are so right.

    • http://www.sweetney.com/ Tracey

      THIS.

  • http://twitter.com/jennamariebee Mrs. Jenna

    I don’t know that I’m so much upset with Rhianna more than I JUST TOTALLY FUCKING HATE CHRIS BROWN AND EVERYTHING TO DO WITH HIM. Pass me a paper bag.

    • MollyGMartin

      Just wanted to check on you… *breathe in, breathe out*

  • Tyskkvinna

    How are we supposed to feel for her the next time it happens? While I’d love to be proven wrong, we all know the chances are higher than zero that it will happen again, at some point, in the future – either with her, or to some other girl by him. Seriously, how should we feel? I’m all for the idea of letting her get on with her life and make her own decisions but that does not tell me how to respond when those decisions are dumb and bad.

    • MollyGMartin

      It’s *the* question. I wish there was a way to keep harping on him (maybe as a warning to his next person) without harping on her… I struggle. I admit.

  • DianaCLT

    Ummmm…it was Josh who was accused of abusing Diane…not the other way around. And I actually do hold it against him. Regardless of race or anything else, I am one of those people that holds grudges against people who beat on other people (and cheat on other people. And a few dozen other things….)

    • MollyGMartin

      Wow…I coulda sworn I didn’t swap the Brolin thing. Thanks for chiming in. I am ALL for holding the grudge against Chris Brown, BTW. And Glen Campbell.

      • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=567438281 Sarah Lee

        It was definitely Josh > Dianne. At the time it was all the gossip, I was all WTF?! NOoo, not Brand! Who’d a thunk that a Goonie would turn out to be such a douche…?

        • DianaCLT

          Douche, he is. And it makes me sad. Because I love her and she seems so sweet and real.

          • MollyGMartin

            Thanks so much, Diana and Sarah. And agree: sad, sad, sad.