Everything I Love Gets Ruined: Instagram’s New Terms Of Service Are Really, Really Bad


Hey, remember when Facebook bought Instagram? And we all made jokes about oh, well, there goes the Kelvin-tinted neighborhood, because Facebook’s gonna dick around with the service and find some way to ruin it because FACEBOOK?

Well. Great news. It’s happening. THE FUTURE IS NOW.

instagram Everything I Love Gets Ruined: Instagrams New Terms Of Service Are Really, Really Bad

YOUR SOUL. LET ME HAVE IT.

The future is January 16, 2013, actually, to be exact. That’s the day Instagram‘s new and most definitely NOT improved Terms of Service (TOS) will go into effect. And while I know mass Internet freak-outs about weird privacy clauses and confusion over copyright law are nothing new, in this case…yeah. These changes suck. Legitimately.

Instagram does not claim ownership of any Content that you post on or through the Service. Instead, you hereby grant to Instagram a non-exclusive, fully paid and royalty-free, transferable, sub-licensable, worldwide license to use the Content that you post on or through the Service, except that you can control who can view certain of your Content and activities on the Service as described in the Service’s Privacy Policy, available here: http://instagram.com/legal/privacy/.

So you own your photos…but you also grant Instagram the rights to use them like their own personal stock photo playground, royalty free. And “sub-licensable” basically means other companies can too, with Instagram’s blessing, BECAUSE…

Some or all of the Service may be supported by advertising revenue. To help us deliver interesting paid or sponsored content or promotions, you agree that a business or other entity may pay us to display your username, likeness, photos (along with any associated metadata), and/or actions you take, in connection with paid or sponsored content or promotions, without any compensation to you. If you are under the age of eighteen (18), or under any other applicable age of majority, you represent that at least one of your parents or legal guardians has also agreed to this provision (and the use of your name, likeness, username, and/or photos (along with any associated metadata)) on your behalf.

Instagram gots to get paid, son. You, on the other hand? You can go fuck yourself., BECAUSE…

You acknowledge that we may not always identify paid services, sponsored content, or commercial communications as such.

Photos of your kids on vacation? Hotel brochure! Artfully shot street photography? Cheesy travel website! Photos of what you ate for brunch? Well. I don’t know about those. The demand for vintage-y photos of mimosas and omelettes is probably way, way less than the current Instagram supply.

But still: Starting on January 16, Instagram plans to sell photos without paying the photographer, or even notifying them that their photos are being used commercially for places and products that they might possibly object to. Could be your photos, could be someone else’s. There is no way to opt out other than to delete your photos and account prior to January 16th. From that point on, even if you delete your account AFTER the new TOS go into effect, you may have granted Instagram and Facebook the rights to use your photos in perpetuity, as there is no language that says deleting your account terminates Instagram’s rights to your previously uploaded photos.

fuuuu10 Everything I Love Gets Ruined: Instagrams New Terms Of Service Are Really, Really Bad

FUUUUUU RAGE IN SEPIA WITH EDGE BLUR

I actually really, genuinely and unironically love Instagram. It’s the only social network I use and check daily. I’m too drama-averse to stomach Twitter on most days, and Facebook lost its appeal for me ages ago. (Coincidentally, around the time that a third-party ad for a diploma mill stole a photo of my baby from my [non-Facebook] blog and I got to witness Facebook’s absolutely TERRIBLE customer service and communication first-hand.) But Instagram, I love.

I love it so much that for Christmas, my BFF had a mosaic canvas made of our past year together, as told via row after row of Instagram photos. All our favorite moments together, with our kids, our families (along with stupid shit like stalking each other with a life-size Harry Potter cut-out and copious amounts of Velveeta dip), were Instagrammed along the way and it was fun and pretty and good.

And while I’m generally pretty chill about the whole “putting photos on the Internet” and understand how copyright works and blah blah blaaaaaah, there’s no fucking way I would ever agree to these new terms from Instragram. Unless this shit gets DRASTICALLY changed (which might still be possible once Instagram fully realizes the Netflix-shaped hole of oh-fuck-we’ve-pissed-everyone-off-and-are-bleeding-users-already they’ve stepped in) I will export my photos and I will delete my account. (Here’s a great list of handy tools you can use for getting all your photos off Instagram.)

Meanwhile, Twitter has released a whole batch of Instagram-style filters for photos (in the wake of re-jiggering their code so Instagram photos weren’t visible anyway), and Flickr is making a belated comeback from the near-dead with their own Instagram-style app (in hopes of people using Flickr for other things besides…posting Instagram photos, probably). I haven’t tried it yet, but have heard good things and Flickr’s TOS is nothing like this new bullshit, so…yeah. I now have the next item on my to-do list once I finish this screed.

Your move, Instagram. Your goddamned move.

source, source, source

About Amy Corbett Storch

Amy blogs at amalah.com, and can be found on Twitter @amalah. She is Team Zombie, though sometimes she is known to side with the Plants.



From Our Partners

  • RiotousDigits

    NO FAIR!! I just started Instagramming this fall and am just hitting my stride! ugh. Time to bring the Flickr out of hibernation.

    • RiotousDigits

      Flickr app is for iPhone only at this time. :(

      • Lucy

        They have an Android one, as well. And it’s had filters for a while.

    • http://www.amalah.com Amalah

      I just spent an hour trying to remember my damn Yahoo! ID and Flickr password (because GOD FORBID I have to sign up as Amalah2 or something), but I did it. Going to play with the app today, but it looks…pretty good so far? Instagram may have really screwed itself here.

  • http://twitter.com/xotrace Tracey GaughranPerez

    They have until January 1st to change this to something not-totally-bullshit, or I’m done. BOO, INSTAGRAM. BOOOOO!

  • Hope

    I use flickr for sharing the photos that I take with my dSLR and hosting the pictures that I have on my blog. I’m one of those weirdos who pays for a pro account, because I have a bazillion albums on there.

    I’ll be glad if this gives them a new lease on life… I was a little worried that they were going to fold and I’d have to figure out what to do with all of my pics.

    • http://www.amalah.com Amalah

      Flickr just posted a response to the kerfluffle on their blog: http://blog.flickr.net/en/2011/05/13/at-flickr-your-photos-are-always-yours

      Translation: We’re not assholes! Come! Switch!

      I stopped using Flickr (and let my Pro account lapse) when I started using my phone more than my DSLR and Flickr’s very first app/mobile upload offerings were really bad. But like you, I’d be happy to see Flickr get a new lease on life too, after everything Yahoo! put them through: http://gizmodo.com/5910223/how-yahoo-killed-flickr-and-lost-the-internet

      • Hope

        I would have loved them extra hard if they’d added “suck it, instagram” to the end of that post. :p

        I should have figured that something was up with instagram when I got a rash of people adding me as a contact on flickr. I thought it was odd at the time, but then it all made sense.

        I played around with the new app for a bit today. It’s definitely an instagram clone, but it seems to work really well. Now I can upload even *more* pictures of my baby. And in sepia!

  • issascrazyworld

    If it weren’t that they’re owned by Facebook, I would fully expect an oh wait our bad we didn’t mean it, like Netflix. However since they’re owned by FB…..

    • http://www.amalah.com Amalah

      As much as I love(d?) Instagram, I probably hate FB more. So…yeah. I’m not super hopeful. Changing the sticking points of the TOS would probably mean FB would have to change their entire business/profit plan for Instagram. Maybe a pro/paid account option (w/ opt-out) will come along?

      • issascrazyworld

        I am with you on FB. MAJORLY. For me…since I am very careful what I put on IG, I am all meh about it. However I’d be deleting mine most likley if I posted anything other than coffee/dessert/sunset photos.

        • http://www.amalah.com Amalah

          Yep. My IG feed is like 90% kid photos. Not fucking around.

    • Tyskkvinna

      They did.

      • http://www.facebook.com/traceygaughranperez Tracey Gaughran-Perez

        Well, not exactly. They said they won’t SELL our photos. However, they didn’t say they wouldn’t use them within Instagram or Facebook paired with ads. There’s still a TON of wiggle room for them to use either our images or our profile pics paired with sponsored content on the site(s) and in-app, which is not something I’m personally at all comfortable with. (“Your friend X loves [insert brand here], and you should too! [with image of you or a photo you took that's related]“) Facebook is notorious for not really giving a shit what its users want (remember last month’s “vote”?), so I’m still pretty dubious and likely not going back. More here: http://gizmodo.com/5969572/instagram-we-dont-want-to-sell-your-photos

        • http://www.facebook.com/traceygaughranperez Tracey Gaughran-Perez

          PS: I agree with what the commenter “blueprint” has to say in comments on that post linked above: “All Instagram really needs to do is answer a *really* simple question: “Will my photos be posted/appear anywhere but my profile & the photostream?”. If “no”, then there’s no reason for the hubbub, and if “yes” then they need to outline precisely how, when, and where.” – Until we hear the answer to that, I think we all have good reason to still be looking around at other options.

          • Tyskkvinna

            Totally agree with you.. though I am fully expecting them to use our profile pictures in some manner in advertising and I have to admit.. I don’t mind.

            that said… I have been have a very fulfilling experience with the Flickr app in the past few days.

          • http://www.facebook.com/traceygaughranperez Tracey Gaughran-Perez

            For some, maybe this won’t be a problem, as you suggest. But I think knowing how our content, likeness, and user data are going to be used is key to making any decision. If they were smart, they’d offer (as Facebook itself does) the option to “opt-out.” Or, better yet, the option to pay a flat fee per month/year/whatever and not have to see or be associated with ANY advertising.

          • http://www.facebook.com/traceygaughranperez Tracey Gaughran-Perez

            Also, I agree, the new flickr app (and their TOS) makes the idea of leaving Instagram completely fairly tempting. ;)

          • Tyskkvinna

            I would totally pay Instagram a few dollars a year to opt out.. especially if it came with some bonus features, like some stupid extra filters or something.

  • http://www.facebook.com/traceygaughranperez Tracey Gaughran-Perez

    Y’all? The new flickr app is sexy-hottness. SOLD.

    • http://www.amalah.com Amalah

      SAME. I just renewed my Pro account and everything. Realizing how much I missed using Flickr to organize my “real” photos too. Albums! Tags! Groups and comments and all kinds of sharing settings!

      THANKS INSTAGRAM.

      • Tyskkvinna

        Same here. I may actually get motivated to take “real pictures” again.. I’ve been ALL IPHONE ALL THE TIME for quite a while now.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=567438281 Sarah Lee

    So in lieu of Instagram going all fuckery, the alternative apps are Flickr AND this other iphone app called, Backspaces! Let’s all go with fingers crossed… G’luck fellow photo folks!

  • http://www.facebook.com/reva.misch Reva A Misch

    I agree with most of you. If this doesn’t get changed, my pictures will be removed & I’ll be off facebook for good.

  • Norm Nelson

    “Netflix-shaped hole” is a good name for a band