From ‘Mama’ To ‘Baby Jane’: The Worst Cinematic Sisters


jessica chastain mama From Mama To Baby Jane: The Worst Cinematic Sisters

Mama, a super creepy-looking horror movie, comes out today. It tells the story of two little girls who have seemingly been living by themselves in an abandoned house in the woods for at least five years. They’re taken in by their uncle and his girlfriend, played by Jessica Chastain. Shockingly, dropping two semi-feral children into the suburbs doesn’t go so smoothly and a spirit who the girls claim is their mother begins to unravel the new family.

Obviously, the villain in this movie is the “Mama” spirit, but from the trailer it looks like the older sister becomes protective of their adoptive mother while the younger sister grins maniacally at Mama’s fucked up antics. But surely she’s not the worst sister in the history of movies. I offer up the following nominees for that dubious honor:

Kym and Rachel in Rachel Getting Married

This movie received a lot of critical praise and Anne Hathaway received an Oscar nomination for her portrayal of Kym. But I really couldn’t get past the fact that Kym and Rachel were both infantile assholes. Kym refuses to get her shit together and Rachel whines constantly about how little attention she gets. They’re exhausting.

Mary and Anne Boleyn in The Other Boleyn Girl

I’ve seen this movie a ridiculous number of times. In fact, the title of it should just be changed to Because There Is Absolutely Nothing Else On. It’s just not a very good movie, but besides that, watching it you forget that Natalie Portman and Scarlett Johanssen are both, in fact, skilled actors. Here they are weighed down by a soap operatic plot, heaving bosoms, and a budget that didn’t leave room for a dialect coach. And the word “sister” (or “sistah” as they pronounce it) is uttered so many times that it somehow begins to sound like it’s not an actual word.

Hannah, Lee, and Holly in Hannah and Her Sisters

Each sister in this Woody Allen classic is dysfunctional in her own way and each betrays the other. One reveals extremely personal information, one has an affair with another’s husband. Ugh, it’s a mess. But for as much groaning as these three sisters cause, it boils down to a wonderful movie that’s a personal favorite. I just couldn’t imagine having to endure a Thanksgiving with them.

Baby Jane Hudson in What Ever Happened to Baby Jane?

Bette Davis plays Baby Jane, the ultimate terrible sister. She’s in charge of caring for her paralyzed sister, Blanche, and for delivering daily doses of WTF as she becomes increasingly detached from the reality of her lost fame. She’s also a terrible cook.

Amy March in Little Women

I’ve always given a gigantic side-eye to Amy and Laurie coming home to Concord all, “Hey! We’re married!” and Jo being all, “Oh? Oh, how wonderful!” and not saying anything along the lines of, “Amy can I talk to you for a second about STEALING THE DUDE I’VE BEEN IN LOVE WITH FOREVER DON’T ACT LIKE YOU DON’T KNOW WHAT I’M TALKING ABOUT!” I mean, it’s great that she shakes it off immediately and is happy for them. But, uh, Jo is a much bigger person than I am, I guess.

Dottie and Kit in A League of Their Own

Dottie never shuts up about how much she hates baseball and how she’s only there for Kit, and Kit is a total brat about how good her sister is at baseball while not acknowledging that Dottie did, in fact, get her into the league. God, I wish these two would quit whining.

source

About Kelly Delaney

Kelly, aka kdiddy, is a full-time working stiff and a part-time angsty writer in Pittsburgh, PA. Her attempts to be a good mom and wife have mixed results.



From Our Partners

  • http://twitter.com/trishwise Trish Kiesau Wise

    dammit, now I have to watch Little Women. It’s been far too long.

    • KellyBDelaney

      It makes me pine for the days when Winona Ryder didn’t make me so uncomfortable.

  • Rapids444

    RE: Little Women. In the book Jo actually had turned down Laurie’s marriage proposal on her own and shows a bit better how sad she was. I think I may have read that book a few too many times along with the sequel “little men”. :D

    • KellyBDelaney

      Right, but in the 1994 movie version that moment is…weird.

    • SuzyQuzey

      Laurie is a man?

      • Rapids444

        Yes, and in the ’94 version of the movie was played by Christian Bale. :) http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0110367/

      • jenny

        and now I’m laughing because Laurie not being a man might make Little Women an entirely different and probably better story.

        • SuzyQuzey

          Right? I want to see THAT version of Little Women.

  • http://www.facebook.com/alexa.shelton Alexa Shelton

    Don’t forget about the crazy murdering sister in So I Married an Axe Murder. Classic movie!

    • KellyBDelaney

      Oh, good one! She was great!

    • http://twitter.com/xotrace Tracey

      SO classic!

  • MollyGMartin

    I loved “rachel getting married” because I knew those sisters were imaginary and I would never have to actually meet them. Great list. What about the Dirty Dancing sisters? Slutty and Ragey, or whomever?

    • KellyBDelaney

      Another good example. If you think of their behavior from their parents’ perspective, it becomes much less tolerable. They’re invited to Kellerman’s as guests because of their dad’s good doctoring, then go about losing their virginity in rather public ways. Then Baby helps to crash the singing of “At Kellerman’s!”

  • SuzyQuzey

    “What Ever Happened to Baby Jane?” is a perennial favorite. My gay BFF and I refer to each other as Blanche all the time.

    • KellyBDelaney

      BUTCHAR