Why You Gotta Be So Mean: Can We Please Stop Slut-Shaming Taylor Swift?


Taylor Swift 590x442 Why You Gotta Be So Mean: Can We Please Stop Slut Shaming Taylor Swift?

Taylor Swift has sold over 22 million albums, and has had almost as many boyfriends in her short life.

I couldn’t be happier for her. But it seems quite a few people aren’t.

Swift has been sneeringly called “a serial dater,” is said to be “addicted to love,” and has otherwise been slut-shamed by the media, the general public, and the toughest and sometimes meanest demographic of all – teenage girls. But aren’t these youthful detractors the same girls who should stand up and cheer Taylor Swift on in her quest of finding a guy who isn’t an asshole is right for her? Her dating history should mean nothing, regardless of it’s width or girth. Yet the volume of reactions to news of her and a new beau would fill a University library (or twelve).

And why do we care so much about Taylor Swift’s dating patterns? Male celebrities who date strings of women escape most if not all of the same criticisms hurled at Swift. Sure, celebrities like George Clooney and Jack Nicholson may “endure”  ribbing for dating numerous women, but it’s mostly good-natured in tone and often targets the woman as the focus of our judgement. If men want to date women through a revolving door, that’s okay, it seems. Let’s celebrate their virility! And aren’t they just so goddamn debonair? Good on them, we say.

(Oh, but not those sluts they date; they’re a bunch of stupid hos, right? Let’s hate on those women! Villagers, gather your torches!)

Look, Taylor Swift is conventionally beautiful, talented, and wealthy. She’s young and single, and has pretty hair that hasn’t yet been puked in by a sick toddler. She doesn’t drown baskets of puppies or steal orphan’s shoes, and by all accounts appears to be a decent person. So – crazy idea alert! – maybe we should just let her keep on keepin’ on as far as her love life goes and STFU about it. If things aren’t good in a relationship, Swift gets out before it gets serious.  This is something she should be congratulated for. This is something to admire, and maybe even to learn from.

It’s curious to note that John Mayer recently gave an interview wherein he admitted to being less-than-great to his ex-girlfriends, saying: “I was just a jerk.” All of a sudden everything Swift had written and sung about after their breakup made sense. The collective of critical voices together murmured, “Okay, we’re all good with her representation of John now, because John said it was true.”

John Mayer Why You Gotta Be So Mean: Can We Please Stop Slut Shaming Taylor Swift?

He hath spoken.

Let the woman date unfettered, I say. We should celebrate Swift’s presentation of dating to our daughters (and ourselves), which is one of not having to settle. She gets in, and if things don’t feel right, she gets out. And that’s what dating is for –otherwise it would be called called marriage.

It’s substantially harder to remove yourself from a shitty legal union because things just don’t feel right, so if Swift is lucky enough to possess working and in-tune “feelers” which alert her to douchbaggery early on (as with Mayer), then more power to her. Do you know what happens to 23 year-old women who never date more than a few partners and say yes to the first person who proposes?  They wind up nine months pregnant before they’re probably truly ready and married to partners who won’t drive two miles to buy them french fries because they “already took their shoes off.”

Or so I hear.

Harry Styles Why You Gotta Be So Mean: Can We Please Stop Slut Shaming Taylor Swift?

Too young?

Taylor Lautner Why You Gotta Be So Mean: Can We Please Stop Slut Shaming Taylor Swift?

Too werewolvey?

Jake Gyllenhaal Why You Gotta Be So Mean: Can We Please Stop Slut Shaming Taylor Swift?

Too gay?

So Taylor, go forth unshamed in your alleged “promiscuity.” Date as many men as you care to, celebs and paupers alike, from both close and far-flung places. Ignore the haters and the shamers, and enjoy yourself. Eventually you will find the right guy – if that’s what you’re looking for – and things will be great. At least until you reach the “mutual fart” stage. Then it’s pretty much all downhill from there.

Read More: Today In Awesome: Samuel L. Jackson Sings Taylor Swift’s “We Are Never, Ever, Ever Getting Back Together”

source, source, source, source, source

About Jeni Marinucci

Jeni is a freelance writer with two children, countless dead hamsters, and a questionable home-haircut. She blogs at Highly Irritable and can be found on Twitter at @highlyirritable



From Our Partners

  • DebC

    Just stop singing mean songs about them.

    • Tiffany

      THIS. If a guy wrote songs about exes the way she does, he’d get so much crap for it! Her personal life is hers to live, but she doesn’t seem to respect the inherent confidentiality of a relationship.

      Don’t get me started, though, on the song where she says she’ll tell everyone her ex is gay.

      • http://www.facebook.com/amanda.robey.50 Amanda Robey

        Wait, what? she said that? In a song? what song? This girl pisses me off because she seems like a cheeky little attention-seeker who will write terrible music (She’s the female version of Justin Bieber. She’s a SHEIBER.) for anyone that will pay. And the whole boyfriend thing only bugs me because of the message it’s sending. I personally don’t care who she bones or doesn’t, nor do I think it makes her a bad person. The bad comes from the message she’s sending, not the one that’s being sent about her. My fella’s cousin is a young girl who recently said on the Facebooks, “Ima just be like Taylor and keep spreading it around til something sticks.” And she meant that in a FLATTERING way. Like a fist-bumpy, this is my idol way.

        • Tiffany

          The song is called Picture to Burn. “So go tell your friends that I’m obsessive and crazy. That’s fine. I’ll tell mine that you’re gay.” She changed the lyrics for the video, but used the gay line in the album version.

          CLASSY!

          • http://www.facebook.com/amanda.robey.50 Amanda Robey

            Well, that’s a bunch of shit. I don’t even know what to say about that, because whoa.

      • http://twitter.com/highlyirritable Jeni M

        She said that? Because if she did, not cool.

        • Tyskkvinna

          She sure did. And then she gets antsy when people are publicly not fond her. Sorry, sweetie – you can behave any way you like, but you better be prepared for people to choose their own reactions to it and it may not be positive!

    • Tyskkvinna

      exactly!!!

  • http://twitter.com/jennamariebee Mrs. Jenna

    I don’t necessarily feel like she’s being slut-shamed. She’s a boyfriend whore. I certainly haven’t entertained the idea that she’s “just getting around.” I think she likes having a boyfriend and like everyone to know when she does. Unfortunately, she likes to let everyone know when they’re not together anymore too. And THAT’s what’s annoying to me.

    • rachel

      You said you don’t feel like she is being slut-shamed and then you called her a whore? Really?

      • http://twitter.com/jennamariebee Mrs. Jenna

        Okay – THAT was taken out of context. Let me rephrase. She REALLY LIKE HAVING A BOYFRIEND. That’s how it was meant.

  • alexa

    I don’t understand why people care. But I feel that way about a lot of the stuff people get worked up about with celebrities. I also think it is pretty funny that the boyfriends are guaranteed a song when they break up with her. They know the risk… I think she should get to enjoy dating as much as she wants. The guys all get to.

    • http://twitter.com/highlyirritable Jeni M

      I would date her if I thought I could get immortalized in a song.

  • .

    She shows little class when she bad mouths her previous relationships publicly. It’s not an endearing quality no matter how many boyfriends she has or hasn’t had. There’s no way that ALL of these men wronged her while she stood in the corner being the victim. She needs to grow up and stop with the woe-is-me facade.

    • http://twitter.com/highlyirritable Jeni M

      Does she do that, though? I know she’s said a few things about past “loves” but as far as I know, some relationships (Kennedy in particular) where simply logistical flops with touring, etc.

      • Tyskkvinna

        It seems, however, that all of them become fodder for her very, very public songs – regardless of how the relationship ended. That’s the main thing about her that rubs me the wrong way.

        • http://twitter.com/highlyirritable Jeni M

          It’s funny; when I told my 13yr old daughter I was writing this article, she said, “Be careful. Taylor may write a song about you.”
          Yikes.

          • Tyskkvinna

            zing! I think your daughter summed up Taylor perfectly.

        • http://www.bookishpenguin.com Candice

          But who cares? How many songwriters write about their exes? Many, many, many. Adele won a bazillion Grammys for an album about her ex. The shaming Swift gets is bizarre in comparison.

          • Tyskkvinna

            Because I’m pretty sure every single song she’s written is about relationships and at that every relationship becomes a song?

          • http://www.bookishpenguin.com Candice

            I guess I just don’t see a problem with that. A famous poet once said in a class I took with him that no one wants to be friends with writers because they know they’ll end up in their novels and poems. I view songwriters the same way.

  • Danielletodd

    I don’t know much about Taylor Swifts music – does she actually name the guys in the songs?

    • http://twitter.com/highlyirritable Jeni M

      I think she did a “Dear John” one after Mayer, but in light of his comments, perhaps it was deserved?

  • http://twitter.com/xotrace Tracey G-P

    1. In my wildest dreams, I never would’ve believed that people would have feelings THIS strong about Taylor Swift.

    2. Regardless, I agree that there’s definitely a double standard when it comes to dating/sex. The ol’ men are adorable scoundrels if they spread themselves around the dating pool liberally, but women are dirty tramps bit. Not sure what, if anything, will change that. SIGH.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=585931384 Tracy Miller

    Wow, I can’t believe how negative some of the comments are! I’ve read a ton of interviews of Taylor Swift, and she never once has pointed fingers at any of the guys that she’s dated, or who have inspired they lyrics in her songs. The media and her fans speculate, but she never confirms. And she’s never specific enough for us to actually be able to tell, but MOST of us can relate to what she sings about.

    She’s made a huge success singing about things that people can relate to, so why should she change it up as long as she’s still selling? I think this will run its course, and she will move on and evolve as a songwriter, but for now, WHO CARES?

    She’s a young woman who dates. She behaves herself in public, seems to be a generally happy-go-lucky person in spite of some of her lyrics, and dresses appropriately (while I know “appropriate” is subjective, I guess what I mean is she’s not flashing girly parts,) and has been nothing but gracious in any venue I’ve ever seen or heard her. So again, WHO CARES?

    • http://twitter.com/highlyirritable Jeni M

      My tent is in your camp, Tracy. I think we project who she is actaully singing about. I mean, songs don’t come out and get on albums mere days after breakups, so we can’t be sure, and moreover, should it matter?

  • Tracy

    I also don’t have a problem with the amount or length of her relationships. Go for it! What I DO have a problem with is the amount of attention she herself has put on them. She’s started complaining recently about everyone wanting to know about her love life. Well, maybe if YOU didn’t make such a big deal out of it….I’m all for using your past relationships for song inspiration, but when those are pretty much the only songs you put out, and you also go through the trouble of putting clues to who they are about in your liner notes….yes, everyone’s going to want to know about it. You kinda brought this on yourself. If it wasn’t such a well known fact that you’ll be getting material out of the relationship, the speculation would probably die down a bit.

  • GirlWithTheKittenTattoo

    I’d love to have the term “slut-shaming” retired.

    • http://twitter.com/OneFunnyMotha OneFunnyMotha

      Me too!

  • Erin

    I myself think the amount of attention paid to her love life by her or anyone else is silly, but I will say she has said in interviews that not all of those songs are about HER exes, she also writes about friend’s experiences as well. Nothing is limited to her. Who cares where they come from? Some people write songs that they just make up. Should we say they just make up stuff and are crazy? I don’t see that rumor going around. Anyways, point is, who cares where her music comes from. It’s music. If its good listen to it. If you don’t like it, change the station.

    • http://twitter.com/highlyirritable Jeni M

      I agree Erin. That’s why I left her actual musical ability out of the article, other than to say she’s clearly talented. She’s relatively young (23?) and writes what she knows – which at this stage is dating and relationships, and as you said, they’re perhaps not always her own experiences.
      Her music isn’t for my taste, but with 22 million albums sold SO FAR, she’s appealing to someone!

  • http://www.josetteplank.com/ Josette Plank

    I don’t know…I don’t want to sound too blase to care about this one way or another, but if pressed, I’d say that I have said the same thing out loud. She’s a young woman. She dates. She’s an artist. She uses her life experiences…of which, really, she’s limited to 20 whatever year’s worth.

    The song Angie was supposed to be about Angela Bowie, or maybe Angie Dickenson, or maybe drugs. You’re So Vain was supposedly about David Geffen. Lynyrd Skynyrd called out Neil Young in a song. Richard Thompson, Joni Mitchell, Suzanne Vega, Billy Joel,Bruce Springsteen…all of these and more are considered “confessional” songwriters, kinda-sorta naming names and places and events in their lives.

    Taylor Swift writes massive hooks and meaningful young-girl-in-and-out-of-love lyrics. Maybe when she’s 40, she’ll be writing massive hooks and meaningful damn-husband-left-me-again songs. And remember: most of what she does *is* country/western music, which has a long history of storytelling about break-ups and hound dogs and old Chevy trucks. She’s right where she needs to be and where plenty were before her.

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=567438281 Sarah Lee

      You’re So Vain was supposed to be about Warren Beatty.

      • http://www.josetteplank.com/ Josette Plank

        According to Wikipedia, Carly Simon said at first that it was a composite of several people, but Beatty almost claimed it for himself. It was a source of question for years, and the story about the intrigue surrounding the song is a pretty interesting read. A lot of possibles were named. And actually, even the David Geffen seems to be a guess.

        • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=567438281 Sarah Lee

          You mean Warren Beatty is SO VAIN that he claimed the You’re So Vain song for himself even though it could have been about others…?! Wow, he is one vain MF! ;)

          • http://www.josetteplank.com/ Josette Plank

            LOL! So true!

  • http://www.facebook.com/hypnotyza Mark ‘Hypnotyza’ Raich

    As an almost-37-year confirmed “dude” (meaning a guy….a male American middle-class, didn’t finish college kinda person), your editorial does provide some interesting food for thought. I suppose that’s why I continue to visit these here parts. (Beyond being personal friends with a regular contributor.)

    I do understand and respect your point of view, and wouldn’t dream of saying something ridiculous like, “you’re wrong”. Because you’re not. Of course, you own your opinion, and you’re entitled to it.

    However, I think there are some sweeping assumptions made on your part that don’t sit well with me. Perhaps it’s me being nit-picky. I leave it up to you to decide:

    1) Legions of songwriters, some of them ensconced in the lore of popular music history, have written songs that were very specifically about their own relationships. The entirety of Fleetwood Mac’s “golden era” revolved around the dissolution of the two married couples in the band writing scathing songs about each other and making them chart-topping hits. And all four of the involved parties wrote.

    And many others have kept their damn traps shut about it.

    I’m just going to go on record here and say that I sort of miss the bygone era when things didn’t have to be explained in painstaking detail, and myths about artists lived longer than their hits…Unlike now, with online journal entries, pics inside the limo Instagram’d, and Live Tweeting of the pre-and-post-Grammy parties…

    I *liked* the mystery in the wordcraft of my favorite artists.

    Even when I knew there was some sort of explicit event, such as the dissolution of Peter Gabriel’s marriage that led to the “Us” album, there was still some mystery and removal of “the real world” that allowed those songs to become a part of MY story when I had a relationship crumbling around me.

    Perhaps it’s the nature of the pop-culture consuming world we live in today that makes it different. Perhaps it’s the way in which Swift has called attention to the fact that her songs are at least partially autobiographical. Perhaps it’s that a lazy journalist can jump from tabloid headline to lyric sheet and connect the dots. I’m not sure. Maybe I’m old and out of touch with my 22 year old self that would eat this stuff up.

    2) Your sweeping assumptions about the public perceptions of the various beaus of Clooney or Nicholson are just…inaccurate. At least with respect to how the male portion of the species views them and their respective partners.

    I know Clooney has dated a few “name” celebrities. But it seems to me he’s reasonable enough to keep their names outta his mouth when asked about them.

    Who the hell knows what Nicholson is up to? I doubt I could name one of his paramours, let alone consciously hate on them.

    But your statement purports to characterize the aforementioned women in a way that I don’t really think is in any way in tune with the “cultural zeitgeist”.

    And furthermore, way to (as you call it) “slut shame” a guy like Clooney, who makes no secret of the fact that he’s not interested in being married.

    ….Is your wrong is just as wrong as the other wrong?

    3) [deleted...mostly because it sounded stupid and preachy and didactic and really doesn't serve a point, considering I'm taking the time to talk about this as much as you are....moving on....]

    4) “Do you know what happens to 23 year-old women who never date more than a few partners and say yes to the first person who proposes?”

    WILD. SWEEPING. STEREOTYPE. ALERT.

    It’s not unheard of, and not every “got married before she was 30″ story has a tragic ending. You got some cultural elitism on yourself there….

    Overall, the theme was headed in the right direction…I just think you could be a little less “eye for an eye” about the argument.

    • http://www.josetteplank.com/ Josette Plank

      I’m a huge Pete Townshend fan – if no one here has guessed this by now – and he is pretty well known as also being an autobiographical writer. He was interviewed on Jon Stewart recently and said, essentially, much of the same thing about the “hyper” storytelling – sort of the liner notes – that happens on Twitter and Facebook and other social media and that is generated by the artists themselves. Suffice to say, he said he didn’t go for that kind of thing and, yes, said that offering too much takes away from the completeness of work of art itself, be it song or poem or painting.

      On the other hand, yes…I’m 46yo and my internal jury is out as to whether all this wide-open-book that social media offers is just not my cup of tea, or the new normal for more and more “kids these days” who will grow up with, first, their own parents telling their story from sometimes pre-conception. Privacy isn’t a given anymore when your own parents are opening up your book. I can imagine that kids will want more and more to get out there and set the record straight – and this in response to parents, friends, and everywhere else someone feels free to make assumptions, comment on who they are, and tell their story. They are saturated in this.

      So I don’t know…does this bombardment make it more difficult to sit back, keep a stiff upper lip, let critics have their say and hope that everyone else will know better than to believe the critical mass of commentary; saying nothing in their defense as their defense, aka “I’m not going to dignify that with a response”?

      Or, I can see a kind of eventual standoff where everyone know that there have been things said about them which aren’t entirely true and that they had little recourse in correcting it, and so think twice when they hear commentary on other people? The positive side of all this is that more people by being burned will become critical thinkers when it comes to hearing crap about other people.

      Anyway…I don’t know if Taylor Swift is thinking this all through, or is just young enough to be differently saturated in social media and trying a different response to everyone else guessing her story. That happened before with older performers, of course. But the sheer number or “citizen journalists” out there now publishing without fact checking may mean this may be the new normal. For a while.

      • http://twitter.com/highlyirritable Jeni M

        I *love* the insight here. Thank you, Josette.

      • http://www.facebook.com/hypnotyza Mark ‘Hypnotyza’ Raich

        Well said, Josette.

        If, in 2013, the tradeoff for being wildly successful is that you have to provide everyone the “behind the scenes play-by-play” as a packaged part of the deal, then you must presume (and accept) that the life portrayed is just as open to critique, criticism, derision, mocking, and mostly, closed-minded opinion as the product that person is peddling.

        And, at the heart of Jeni’s article, I agree that there is a ridiculous double standard in play. It’s not fair. It’s not right. But all artists serve the “court of public opinion” at the king’s pleasure…and the king is the American public. For better or worse, they love “breaking you” as much if not more than “making you”.

  • http://twitter.com/OneFunnyMotha OneFunnyMotha

    I think I love you. I know I’m late in weighing in here, but despite her dating life I feel like Taylor Swift is perhaps the only female role model across the entire entertainment industry I wouldn’t mind my daughter (12) looking up to. She sings innocent songs without profanity or misogynistic lyrics, she dresses appropriately without letting sex sell what she lacks in tallent, she carries herself with dignity, she’s hard working and she’s ambitious. She’s fairly wholesome & I just don’t get the zeal people have in bashing her. And for what? Because she makes some mistakes in her dating life? Who hasn’t at 23? We finally have a decent role model for our daughters and what do people do? Bash her.

  • http://www.facebook.com/dani.heart.75 Dani Heart

    Great post and so true. I am glad for her really.. that is what dating is about. It’s not serious nor should it be until you know it’s right. Go Taylor!